Information

Easily confused fish

The pairs anglers mix up most often -- some matter legally: the crucian carp is protected, the Prussian carp isn't.

Prussian carp · Crucian carp

Prussian carp
Prussian carp
Crucian carp
Crucian carp

It matters legally: the crucian carp is protected.

  • Crucian carp: a higher, rounded back, golden-bronze colour, a black spot at the base of the tail in young fish, the edge of the dorsal fin curving outwards.
  • Prussian carp: silvery, a less deep body, the edge of the dorsal fin straight or slightly concave.

⚠ If you're not sure, release it.

Carp · Prussian carp

Carp
Carp
Prussian carp
Prussian carp

The barbels.

  • The carp has 4 barbels (two small and two larger) at the corners of its mouth.
  • Prussian carp and crucian carp have no barbels.

Bream · Silver bream · Blue bream

Bream
Bream
Silver bream
Silver bream
Blue bream
Blue bream

The fins and the eye.

  • Bream: dark, long fins, a lot of slime, small scales.
  • Silver bream: paired fins reddish at the base, a large eye, larger scales.
  • Blue bream: a larger eye than the bream and a very long anal fin.

Zander · Perch

Zander
Zander
Perch
Perch

The stripes and the teeth.

  • Perch: clear vertical stripes, red pelvic and anal fins, a black spot at the end of the first dorsal fin.
  • Zander: an elongated, greenish-grey body, without clear stripes, spotted dorsal fins, large canine teeth.

Zander · Volga zander

Zander
Zander
Volga zander
Volga zander

Size and stripes.

  • The Volga zander is smaller, with clearer dark vertical bars.
  • The common zander is larger, greenish, with large canines.

Rudd · Roach

Rudd
Rudd
Roach
Roach

The mouth and the eye.

  • Rudd: an upturned mouth, all fins red.
  • Roach: a terminal mouth, a red spot in the eye.

Chub · Asp · Ide

Chub
Chub
Asp
Asp
Ide
Ide

The mouth and the body.

  • Chub: a broad head, a large mouth, a cylindrical body, a convex anal fin edge.
  • Asp: a very wide mouth, split back to below the eye, a more elongated body.
  • Ide: a deeper body, a smaller mouth, reddish fins.

Brown trout (native mountain trout) · Rainbow trout · Brook trout

Brown trout (native mountain trout)
Brown trout (native mountain trout)
Rainbow trout
Rainbow trout
Brook trout
Brook trout

The spots.

  • Brown trout: red spots with a pale halo, no pink band.
  • Rainbow trout: a pink band along the flank, small black spots, including on the tail.
  • Brook trout: vermiculations (worm-like markings) on the back and white edges on the lower fins.

Silver carp · Bighead carp

Silver carp
Silver carp
Bighead carp
Bighead carp

The head and the colour.

  • Bighead carp: a very large head, a darker body with irregular blotches.
  • Silver carp: lighter in colour, silvery, a smaller head.

Wels catfish · Brown bullhead (American catfish)

Wels catfish
Wels catfish
Brown bullhead (American catfish)
Brown bullhead (American catfish)

The barbels and the adipose fin.

  • Wels catfish: 6 barbels (2 long on top, 4 short below), no adipose fin, grows very large.
  • Brown bullhead: 8 barbels, has an adipose fin (a small fleshy fin on the back, towards the tail), rarely over 30 cm.

⚠ The brown bullhead is invasive: don't release it.

Zingel · Streber (small zingel)

Zingel
Zingel
Streber (small zingel)
Streber (small zingel)

Both are protected.

  • Zingel streber: smaller, with 4-5 clear oblique bars.
  • Zingel zingel: larger, with irregular blotches.

⚠ Both are released, all year round.

Perch · Ruffe

Perch
Perch
Ruffe
Ruffe

The dorsal fin.

  • Perch: two separate dorsal fins, vertical stripes, red fins.
  • Ruffe: a single long dorsal fin, a finely spotted body, no red.

Bleak · Spirlin

Bleak
Bleak
Spirlin
Spirlin

The lateral line.

  • Spirlin: a double lateral line dotted with black.
  • Bleak: no dotted line, uniformly silvery.

Photos: Wikimedia Commons (authors and licences are in “Identify the fish”).

The photos and full descriptions are in the species guide (“Identify the fish”), with a direct comparison between species.